review of the Sony PRS-505 ebook reader
As I mentioned in comments to this post
I ended up buying the Sony ebook reader
because I could go down to Target and get instant gratification rather than ordering and having to wait for it to be delivered.
All in all, the purchase was a success and may even save me money. Since I moved and did not get cable TV at my new place, I have been buying about one paperback a week: that's about seven or eight dollars a week. Since I bought the PRS-505, I've read nothing but free books. So far I've finished a collection of books and stories by Keith Laumer called "A Plague of Demons" that I downloaded from Baen Free Library
(thanks to Foxfier
for the reminder) and I've finally read "Dracula" which I downloaded from The Guttenberg Project
Reading is very nearly as comfortable as a paperback but not quite. The disadvantages I've seen so far are
(1) contrast is not as high as black print on white paper,
(2) glare is a bit more noticeable than it is on non-glossy paper,
(3) the device is heavier than a paperback (but I have read heavier hard-covers)
(4) there is a slightly distracting delay and flash when you turn the page
(5) you can't always find the books you want as e-books
For me, the disadvantages are outweighed by the advantages:
(1) it is more compact than a large paperback
(2) whenever I have the device with me I have several thousands of pages of reading to choose from
(3) I now have a convenient way to read all of the free ebooks that have been too awkward to read before.
For other people, the fact that you can buy new books and download them from the internet would be an advantage, but it is not an advantage to me. I like going to book stores.
My overall reaction is that the technology still needs some improvement, but it is adequate now. If you like older (that is, free :0) books or if you just have a long commute by bus or train and like to read, this could be a worthwhile investment. Of course if you are just a technophile, you don't need those kinds of justifications, just the assurance that the technology actually does what it claims. As far as I am concerned, it does.
UPDATE: I'm having second thoughts now that I have actually tried to buy something for the PRS505. The limited selection of formats is turning out to be a problem
e--book readers: Amazon vs. open standards
The big story going around the blogosphere this weekend is Amazon's behavior
in deleting books from other people's computers (link from Instapundit
who has done a good job of covering this even though he must make a lot of money from Amazon). The Amazon Kindle is an e-book reader --a small device designed to let you read electronic books. E-book screens are e-paper (rather than LCD), a technology that gives better-quality reading and uses natural light rather than back lighting. It looks like a neat toy and I'm planning to buy an e-book reader sometime in the next couple of weeks.
If you have a Kindle, you can buy e-books from Amazon and download them into the device. What Amazon didn't tell you is that they have the ability to not only download books onto the device but also the ability to delete books from the device. And they recently did just that after complaints from a copyright holder, with no request for permission --they just deleted books that people had bought.
They claim that it's OK because they credited people's accounts for the money, but I don't think that covers it. First, if someone paid ten dollars for the book then it must be because they thought the book was worth more than ten dollars. So they haven't been repaid what they valued the book at. Second, some percentage of these people will never see that ten dollar credit, either because they lose their account information or because they never make another purchase from Amazon, or for some other reason. A ten-dollar credit is not the same a cash money and I'm pretty sure that it is not legal tender.
And besides that, when has it ever been acceptable for someone to sneak something away from you and give you back what you paid for it? Does it become not-theft if a pickpocket grabs your watch and leaves you money in your pocket? What about the people who were in the middle of reading one of the books? I don't know about you, but when I'm reading a good book I couldn't stand to lose it before I'm finished.
Is this a dealbreaker for would-be Kindle purchasers?
It is for me. I was wavering between the Kindle with Amazon's leadership on-line content and an open-standards alternative, but now I'm going for open standards. In a way I'm glad this happened because letting one company control your library is a very bad idea and it would have come back to haunt me sooner or later.
So I've been doing my research
and I'm leaning towards one of these:
HanLin eBook V3 supports more formats than the other two and has the longest batter life but is also the bulkiest and only has one content partner. However, it can be used with content from other e-book companies.
Sony PRS-505 has the fewest open formats that it supports and is the most likely, in my opinion, to have Kindle-like drawbacks --I'm not sure how open it is to other content providers-- but it is supported by a huge electronics company and three major publishers. And I've been able to see it myself at a local Target store. It has more gray shades than the others, but I'm not sure if I care. I'm not planning to use this for images.
Bookeen Cybook Gen3 is the smallest of the three (so the most likely to fit in a jacket pocket). It supports more formats than the Sony and is less likely to be tied to specific e-book providers.
None of these devices has wireless connectivity, but I'm wondering how big a deal that is. With all of the free e-books
available I'm more likely to have a hundred books on the thing that I'll never get around to reading than I am to be caught with nothing to read.